The Civil War is a dramatic event in the history of our country. Riot is
a moving work of historical fiction by Walter Dean Myers that shares
a retelling of a little known aspect of our nation's story. The
entire storyline covers the four days in July 1863 when the New
York City draft riots occurred. Great civil unrest showed its head
in the worst race riots ever experienced in our nation's history
as struggling Irish immigrants protested being drafted to fight
for the freedom of "darkies" in the Civil War. Bloody attacks,
looting, arson, and murder were seen throughout the city.
The story is told as a personal narrative from a 15-year-old biracial
girl, Claire. As the daughter of a black father and an Irish mother,
Claire not only witnesses the tragic events unfolding outside her
door but also faces an internal battle as she searches for her
own identity in the two worlds that war against each other. Who
is she? Where does she belong? In the end, whom will she be able
to call "friend"? What will the community she calls home look like,
and how will the people there receive her?
Riot is written in screenplay format. It contains a
cast of characters, a timeline of the historical events that provide
the setting of this piece of fiction, and author's notes in the
closing of the book that provide additional insights. The text
of the story occupies 154 pages.
The screenplay format of the book was somewhat challenging to
get into at the beginning. I found myself flipping between the
storyline and the cast of characters in order to keep everyone
straight and to keep the dialogue in context. This became less
necessary as the story progressed. By the end, I realized how little
we read in this format and began considering the value of this
exposure for my children.
Riot would be appropriate for middle school and high
school students. Students in these age groups will readily relate
to the narrative voice of a 15-year-old and will be challenged
to realize that history affects people of all ages, not just soldiers
and politicians.
Riot could be very powerfully used in a homeschool co-op,
with the students taking on individual roles and reading the screenplay
in character. Assignments could include research projects on this
event, reflections on what it would have been like to live during
this era, and the impact such events had on the cultural shaping
of our country today. Riot would also be great supplemental
reading material for any family completing a unit on the Civil
War.
Product review by Dawn Oaks, The Old Schoolhouse® Magazine,
LLC, May 2011
|