The Old Schoolhouse Magazine
Print PageClose Window
The Old Schoolhouse Magazine
Boy, Bird, and Dog

David McPhail
Holiday House, Inc.
www.holidayhouse.com

425 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10017

Boy, Bird, and Dog is a picture book for beginning readers. Boy and Bird are up in the tree house, and Dog wants to join them, but he can't climb the ladder. Boy figures out a way to haul Dog up, and all three friends enjoy the view. Boy is then able to use his system to haul up cookies from Mom, and all three enjoy the treat.

The illustrations in Boy, Bird, and Dog are very sweet, as is the plot. However, the sentences are extremely short and choppy, even for a beginning reader, and the grammar is troubling at times. For instance, when Boy, Bird, and Dog are in the tree house looking out at the yard, the sentence used to describe this is "They saw and saw." This is not what I want my beginning reader to view as an acceptable sentence (and it is repeated). I think there are better options available for beginning readers, so I would recommend skipping Boy, Bird, and Dog.



Product Review by Courtney Larson, The Old Schoolhouse® Magazine, LLC, March, 2012


The Old Schoolhouse Magazine
Print PageClose Window
©2013 TheHomeschoolMagazine.com is a division of The Old Schoolhouse® Magazine, LLC. All rights reserved.
No content may be removed or used without permission from TheHomeschoolMagazine.com.
Webmaster    Legal   Site Map   Advertise